Our Insurance Carriers

One of the biggest advantages of working with an independent insurance agency like Holley Insurance? We’re not tied to just one company.

Instead, we partner with a variety of top-rated insurance carriers so we can shop around for you—comparing coverage, pricing, and discounts to find the best fit for your situation. Whether you’re looking for home, auto, business, or specialty coverage, we’ve got options.

If you need to contact your carrier directly, we've compiled their contact information in the table below.

---

Cincinnati Insurance

Cincinnati is known for high-quality coverage and top-notch claims service. They’re a great fit if you’re looking for a more personalized insurance experience, especially for home, auto, or business policies.

---

Erie Insurance

Erie is a client favorite—and for good reason. They consistently rank high in customer satisfaction and offer solid coverage at competitive prices for home, auto, and business insurance.

---

Foremost Insurance

Have something a little outside the box? Foremost specializes in covering unique risks like mobile homes, motorcycles, RVs, and rental properties—perfect when a standard policy doesn’t quite cut it.

---

Grange Insurance

Grange offers flexible coverage options with a strong focus on customer service. They’re a dependable choice for both personal and business insurance needs.

---

Nationwide

You’ve probably heard the name—and they live up to it. Nationwide offers a wide range of coverage options, making them a great choice if you’re looking to bundle your home, auto, and more all in one place.

---

Northern Neck Insurance

Northern Neck focuses primarily on homeowners insurance and is known for simple, reliable coverage. They’re a great regional option with a strong reputation for stability.

---

Progressive

Progressive is one of the go-to names for auto insurance, offering competitive rates and flexible options. They also shine when it comes to motorcycles, boats, and other recreational vehicles.

---

Travelers

Travelers is a well-established carrier offering comprehensive coverage for home, auto, and business insurance. They’re a great all-around option with a long history of reliability.

---

Why It Matters

More carriers = more options.

That means we can compare policies, find better pricing, and make sure you’re not overpaying for coverage you don’t need (or missing coverage you do). Our job is to do the shopping for you—and make the process easy.

Company	Billing	Claims
Cincinnati Insurance	1.800.364.3400 Pay Bill Online	1.877.242.2544 File Claim Online
Erie Insurance	1.800.458.0811 Pay Bill Online	1.800.322.3743 File Claim Online
Foremost Insurance	1.800.532.4221 Pay Bill Online	1.800.527.3907 File Claim Online
Grange Insurance	1.866.550.9222 Pay Bill Online	1.800.445.3030 File Claim Online
Nationwide Insurance	1.888.891.0267 Pay Bill Online	1.800.421.3535 File Claim Online
Northern Neck Virginia Insurance	1.800.552.8660 Pay Bill Online	1.877.968.7252 File Claim Online
Progressive Insurance	1.800.876.5581 Pay Bill Online	1.800.274.4499 File Claim Online
Travelers Insurance	1.800.842.5075 Pay Bill Online	1.800.252.4633 File Claim Online